Guide

PAC 2024 errors explained: every failure and its fix

What each failing line in a PAC 2024 report means, the PDF/UA condition behind it, and how to fix it, from “Pages with annots have tab order S” to role maps.

About 8 minutes · quick

The whole table is also open data: JSON and CSV, every condition with its PAC 2024 and Acrobat names, free to reuse with attribution.

How to use this page

Find the line from your PAC 2024 report in the tables further down this page. Each row names the PDF/UA condition behind the line and links to its page: what is wrong in the file, what a screen reader does with it, and how to fix it free in Acrobat Pro. The last column says whether Taggart repairs it automatically, proposes a repair for your decision, or leaves it to you.

PAC’s detailed messages are taken from axes4’s help articles; its summary lines are written as people search for them and have not yet been compared with PAC itself. If the line in your report reads differently, search the tables for its key words — a role map, a tab order, a heading level — and tell us what it said, so the page can be corrected.

Only the lines this site already explains are here, which is a part of the 136 conditions in the Matterhorn Protocol. The list of every condition gives Taggart’s plain-language title for each of the rest.

What PAC passes that still fails people

A clean PAC report means the conditions software can decide have passed. Two kinds of failure get through it.

Text stored in visual order. Hebrew and Arabic PDFs from older systems often store each line reversed. The page looks right, and PAC accepts it, because no Matterhorn condition tests the order text is stored in. A screen reader then reads the line backwards. Right-to-left text stored in visual order explains the failure and how to find it with nothing but copy and paste.

The conditions only a person can decide. Forty-seven of the protocol’s conditions need human judgement: whether the tags are in the order a person reads the page (09-001), whether a custom tag is mapped to the right standard one (02-002), whether alt text says what an image is there for. PAC’s screen-reader preview helps a person judge the first. No checker can pass or fail any of them for you, and that includes Taggart.

When PAC and Acrobat disagree

They are different lists. Acrobat’s Full Check runs 32 rules of its own, tests some things PDF/UA does not require, and misses many of the Matterhorn conditions PAC tests. When a line appears in one report and not in the other, look up both: Acrobat’s accessibility checker, rule by rule does for Acrobat what this page does for PAC.

We have not yet cross-checked Taggart against PAC either. Where the two disagree about a file, read both findings, and tell us — that is how the comparison gets done.

Then fix the file

Taggart checks the same file free, with no account needed up to 60 pages, and with a free account it runs its repairs on your file so you can see what they change: check a PDF free.

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Alternative text

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Alternative text”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Form field has TU key28-005: A form field has neither a TU entry nor an alternative descriptionThe /TU tooltip is the accessible name of a PDF form field. Without it the field has no name at all — the visible label printed next to it is not connected to the control.Proposed for your decision

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Annotations

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Annotations”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Widget annotations in Form tag28-010: A widget annotation is not nested within a Form tagEvery form control must sit inside a Form structure element.Applied automatically
Link annotations in Link tag28-011: A link annotation is not nested within a Link tagA link annotation must be a child of a Link structure element containing the link's text, joined by an object reference (/OBJR).Proposed for your decision

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Content

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Content”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
No tagged content in artifact01-004: Tagged content is present inside content marked as ArtifactA marked-content sequence for real content has been opened inside an open artifact sequence. The artifact swallows the real content.Applied automatically

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Document settings

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Document settings”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Pages with annots have tab order S28-008: A page containing an annotation does not contain a Tabs entryAny page carrying annotations must declare a tab order. PDF/UA-1 requires /Tabs /S — tab order follows the structure tree.Applied automatically
Pages with annots have tab order S28-009: A page containing an annotation has a Tabs entry with a value other than S/Tabs is present but set to /R (row order) or /C (column order) rather than /S (structure order).Applied automatically

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Headings

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Headings”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
First heading is H114-002: First heading tag is not H1The document uses numbered headings (H1–H6) but the first one encountered in the structure tree is not an H1.Applied automatically
No headings skipped14-003: Numbered heading levels in descending sequence are skippedThe heading hierarchy jumps a level going down — H1 straight to H3. Going back up any number of levels is fine; going down must be one level at a time.Applied automatically

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Metadata

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Metadata”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Document contains title06-003: XMP metadata stream does not contain dc:titleThe Dublin Core title property is missing from the XMP packet.Proposed for your decision

PAC 2024: PDF/UA › Role map

PAC 2024 lines under “PDF/UA › Role map”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Non-standard structure type is remapped02-001: Non-standard tag mapping does not terminate with a standard typeA custom tag name is present in the role map but the chain of mappings never arrives at a structure type defined in ISO 32000-1, 14.8.4. Mapping may be indirect — a custom type may map to another custom type — but it must eventually terminate.Applied automatically

PAC 2024: Detailed results

PAC 2024 lines under “Detailed results”, with the condition behind each
The line in the reportConditionWhat it meansTaggart’s fix
Artifact present inside tagged content01-003: Content marked as Artifact is present inside tagged contentA BMC/BDC artifact sequence has been opened while a marked-content sequence for real content is still open. Artifacts and real content may not be nested inside one another.Applied automatically
Tagged content present inside an Artifact01-004: Tagged content is present inside content marked as ArtifactA marked-content sequence for real content has been opened inside an open artifact sequence. The artifact swallows the real content.Applied automatically
Non-standard structure type "…" is neither mapped to a standard structure type nor to another non-standard structure type02-001: Non-standard tag mapping does not terminate with a standard typeA custom tag name is present in the role map but the chain of mappings never arrives at a structure type defined in ISO 32000-1, 14.8.4. Mapping may be indirect — a custom type may map to another custom type — but it must eventually terminate.Applied automatically
Structure type "…" is mapped in a circular fashion02-003: A circular mapping existsThe role map contains a cycle: A maps to B, B maps back to A. Resolution never terminates.Applied automatically
Standard structure type "…" is remapped to "…"02-004: One or more standard types are remappedA standard structure type appears as a key in the role map — for example /P mapped to /Span. Standard types must never be remapped; doing so redefines the vocabulary the whole file depends on.Applied automatically
First heading is not on the first level14-002: First heading tag is not H1The document uses numbered headings (H1–H6) but the first one encountered in the structure tree is not an H1.Applied automatically
Numbered heading skips one or more heading levels14-003: Numbered heading levels in descending sequence are skippedThe heading hierarchy jumps a level going down — H1 straight to H3. Going back up any number of levels is fine; going down must be one level at a time.Applied automatically
Alternate field name entry missing in form field28-005: A form field has neither a TU entry nor an alternative descriptionThe /TU tooltip is the accessible name of a PDF form field. Without it the field has no name at all — the visible label printed next to it is not connected to the control.Proposed for your decision
Tab order entry in page with annotations not set to S28-008: A page containing an annotation does not contain a Tabs entryAny page carrying annotations must declare a tab order. PDF/UA-1 requires /Tabs /S — tab order follows the structure tree.Applied automatically
Tab order entry in page with annotations not set to S28-009: A page containing an annotation has a Tabs entry with a value other than S/Tabs is present but set to /R (row order) or /C (column order) rather than /S (structure order).Applied automatically
Widget annotation not nested inside a Form structure element28-010: A widget annotation is not nested within a Form tagEvery form control must sit inside a Form structure element.Applied automatically
Link annotation is not nested inside a Link structure element28-011: A link annotation is not nested within a Link tagA link annotation must be a child of a Link structure element containing the link's text, joined by an object reference (/OBJR).Proposed for your decision

Frequently asked questions

Is PAC 2024 free?

Yes. PAC 2024 is free of charge, from axes4. It checks and fixes nothing, and its screen-reader preview, which shows the text in the order a reader would announce it, is the part most worth opening.

Does PAC run on a Mac?

No, PAC is Windows-only. On a Mac, axesCheck, the free browser checker from PAC's makers, runs the same kind of checks; veraPDF is cross-platform, free and open source, and covers the same PDF/UA-1 clauses; and Taggart's validator runs in any browser. Between them you can get an independent second opinion without a virtual machine.

Related guides

Related failure conditions

Check your own file. Taggart's validator is free and unlimited — no page cap, no watermark, and no account at all up to 60 pages. To repair a file rather than check it, see how Taggart’s repairs work.

Check a PDF free

Last updated .